Skip to content
Buying in the Hudson Valley

Property taxes and school districts in Putnam County.

Two houses at the same price, a few miles apart, can cost very different amounts every month. Most of that difference is the tax bill, and most of the tax bill is the school district. Here is what to check before you make an offer.

In New York, a property tax bill is really several taxes. There is a school tax, and there is a town and county tax, and they arrive as separate bills on separate schedules. In Putnam County and northern Westchester the school tax is usually the largest share, which is why the school district a house sits in matters more to the bill than the town name on the mailing address.

That is also why the tax number on a listing is often wrong, or at least incomplete. It may show one bill and not the other, a bill from a prior year, or a bill reduced by exemptions that belong to the seller and leave with them. Buyers who compare houses on list price alone can end up with a larger monthly payment than the house they passed on.

Larry has watched this play out for more than forty years of closings across Putnam, Westchester and Dutchess. The checks below take an afternoon, and they are worth doing before an offer, not after.

Look at the Taxes, Not Just the Price

Read the transcript
Before you make an offer

Six things to check on any house.

None of these need a lawyer or a lender. They need the tax bills and a few questions to the listing agent.

01

Find the parcel's real school district

Up here the mailing address and the school district often disagree. A Mahopac mailing address does not guarantee the Mahopac school district, and a single town can be split between two or three districts. The district is what drives most of the bill, so confirm it from the tax bill itself or from the town assessor, never from the listing or a portal.

02

Ask for the actual tax bills, not the listing estimate

Ask the listing agent for the most recent school tax bill and the most recent town and county bill. In New York they are separate bills on separate schedules, and listings often show one, an old one, or a rounded total. Two real bills tell you more than any estimate.

03

Check which exemptions the seller has

This is the one that catches people. Exemptions belong to the owner, not the house. If the seller has a senior, veteran or other exemption on the bill, that discount ends when they sell, and your bill can be noticeably higher than theirs. Look at the exemption lines on the bill and ask what the full, unexempted tax would be.

04

Know the STAR difference

Many longtime owners still receive the STAR school tax exemption directly on their bill. New homeowners generally receive STAR as a credit check from New York State instead, if they qualify, and they have to register for it. Same benefit in many cases, different paperwork, and it will not show up on your bill the way it shows up on the seller's.

05

Put the tax into the monthly payment

Your lender collects property tax monthly through escrow and counts it when deciding what you qualify for. A house with a lower price and a higher tax bill can cost more every month than a house with a higher price and a lower tax bill. Compare the full monthly payment, not the list price.

06

Look at the assessment, then remember you can challenge it

Each town assesses property at its own fraction of market value, so an assessed value in one town cannot be compared to another. What matters is whether this house is assessed fairly next to similar houses in the same town. If it is not, New York gives owners a yearly chance to grieve the assessment with the town, and a further review process after that.

The trade-offs

Price, taxes and the long run.

Nobody explains this part, so here it is plainly.

Lower taxes usually mean a higher price

Buyers notice tax differences, so they tend to show up in what houses sell for. A lower-tax area often comes with higher prices for similar houses. You are rarely getting both a low price and low taxes on the same street, which is why the monthly comparison matters more than either number alone.

Taxes are a cost you pay every year

Price is paid once and financed. Taxes are paid every year for as long as you own the house, and they tend to rise over time. If you plan to stay for a long time, a difference in the yearly tax bill adds up to real money.

Resale buyers will make the same comparison

Whoever buys the house from you will run these same numbers. The tax bill, the district and the assessment are part of what you are buying, and part of what you will eventually be selling.

Researching schools

Do your own homework on the schools.

Choosing a school district is your decision, and fair housing rules mean a real estate agent should not steer you toward or away from one. What Larry can do is tell you exactly which district a house is in, what its tax bill really is, and how that compares with the other houses on your list.

For the schools themselves, go to the source. The New York State Education Department publishes data for every public district, each district publishes its own budget every spring, and district budgets go to a public vote, so you can see where the school tax goes. Visit, ask questions, and talk to people who live there.

Next step

Comparing a few houses?

Send Larry the addresses. He will pull the real tax bills and districts and show you what each one actually costs per month, before you fall in love with the wrong number. Call or text (914) 282-6440.

Lawrence Zacks, Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker

Written by Lawrence Zacks

Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker, License #10301205239 · Selling in Putnam County since 1982 · Published

General information, not legal or tax advice. Tax rates, exemptions, STAR rules and assessment deadlines change every year and differ by town. Confirm current figures with the town assessor, the receiver of taxes and your attorney. Moving up from the south? Read Moving from Westchester to Putnam, or browse all Resources.